Bedford Cheese Shop and P&H Soda Co Complaints - Sells Out of Date - Stale Soda Syrup

Last week I purchased 4 bottles of from

Bedford Cheese Shop for $58.00

My wife wanted a soda treat, but the trick was on her.

The syrup was stale, rancid, and disgusting.

Bedford Cheese Shop refused a refund and said to call the manufacture pnh soda and syrup.

Spoke to the owner Anton Nocito a condescending wise ***, said he didn't sell us the soda and we should take it up with Bedford Cheese Shop.

This fly by night operator, who lacks a 4 year college degree sells defective syrup products load with sugar concentration and intestinal bacteria.

read this review from a doctor that lab tested the pnh soda and syrup;

I'm surprise Martha Stweart lent her name to this product. But what do you expect from an ex ***.

I lost my money, and my wife and I suffered 3 days of the runs!

Be safe and smart; stay away from until they are FDA approved and inspected.

Thank you,

Anthony Tizzi

This review is a subjective opinion of a user.
Report Comment Private message author

More Review Details

Product or service
Ph Soda
Review category
Food Stores
review #244567 by
Had an experience with Bedford Cheese Shop? Submit review ›
Helpful? 1 Yes 1 0 No 0
Had the same issue 0 Yes 0
Comment as anonymous As anonymous or Log in
OR Is it your business? Respond to your
customers as verified company representative.
Apply for a Free Plan

Jul 21, 2013 #684758 New York City, New York

This is one of the worst sodas I ever tasted. And the owner is a creep too!
Being that he touts his beverage as being 'all natural' but uses cane sugar ... one of the worst foods you should eat ... puts it on my 'AVOID' list.

After seeing a video about his operation I was eager to try it but was hesitant about all the sugar he uses. So I emailed him and suggested he uses stevia, a much better natural sweetener ... and he fluffed me off, saying it didn't work as well as sugar.

Then on July 17th in Union Sq pk they were staying open late to introduce the public to tastings of nearby restaurants, and P&H was going to be selling their sodas there.

So I went to try them. He had no samples, and wouldn't even put a drop on my finger to taste any one of them. So I bought a $3 ginger soda ... I should have stopped there. It was very blah. Instead a sprung for a $10 bottle of sarsaparilla and made one when I got home. It tastes NOTHING like sarsaparilla ... I can't even describe the taste ... only to say it is awful.

If this place is still in business next year ... I will be shocked!
Don't waste your money on P&H soda ... Perrier has more taste and is better for you!
:sigh :(

1 0 Reply
debbie lancer

Jul 31, 2011 #321013

P&H SODA is God Awful

$12 for a bottle of sugar water UGHHHH

1 0 Reply
roger whitlock

Jul 03, 2011 #307662

thank you for the heads up

saw this product in a store
was hesitant to buy because I never of this
company before, and they did not list
their office address on the bottle label.

you have to be careful of these
fly by night food vendors
and what digest into your body
the p&H soda Co must have something to hide

0 0 Reply
Great comment! Would you like to convert it into review?

You will be able to edit the text before publishing.

× You are about to contact

Review submitted through "Contact Us" will not get published on the site or forwarded to Bedford Cheese Shop. However, many companies do monitor reviews on our site.

You were reading a complaint about Bedford Cheese Shop.
Filing a new complaint about